The Asian Civil Engineering Coordinating Council
(ACECC)
The Fourth Executive Committee Meeting |
9:00 to 15:00, April 16, 2001
Crown Plaza Metropolitan Hotel
|
MINUTES |
The 4th Executive Committee Meeting of the Asian Civil Engineering Coordinating Council was held at Crown Plaza Metropolitan Hotel in Tokyo , Japan on April 16, 2001 from 9:00 to 15:00. The following were present at the meeting.
American Society of Civil Engineers
1. Dr. Alfred Ang, International Director, ASCE
2.Mr. Noel Raufaste, Managing Director, Technical and International Activities, ASCE
3.Ms. Marisa Sherard, Sr. Manager International Affairs, ASCE
Chinese Institute of Civil and Hydraulic Engineering
1. Dr. John Chien-Chung Li, President, CICHE
2. Mr. Chi-Shou Hsieh, Executive Director, CICHE
3. Dr. Jenn-Chuan Chern, Executive Director, CICHE
4. Mr. Sen-Yuan Chang, Supervisor, CICHE
5. Mr. Wan-Ning Liu, Chairman, International Relations Committee, CICHE
6. Mr. Chia-Yih Chu, Secretary General. CICHE
Korean Society of Civil Engineers
1. Dr. Kwang-Il Kim, President, KSCE
2. Dr. Chun-Su Chon, Vice President, KSCE
3. Dr. Sung-Wan Hong, Director, KSCE
4. Mr. Moon-Sam Chang, Director, KSCE
5. Mr. Jae-Gwon Cho, Manager, KSCE
Philippines Institute of Civil Engineers
1. Mr. Efren H. Sison, President, PICE
2. Mr. Bashir D. Rasuman, Past President and Chair of the International Affairs Committee(IAC), PICE
3. Mr. Felipe F. Cruz, Past President and Special Adviser of the IAC,
4. Mr.Peter N. Aventajado, Treasurer, PICE
5. Mr. Willy T. Go, Vice President and Member, International Affairs 4. M Committee, PICE
6. Ms. Antonina (Nannette) C. Villanueva, National Administrative Officer, PICE
Vietnam Construction Association
1. Dr. Nguyen Truong Tien, Member of the Executive Board, VCA
The Institution of Engineers, Australia
1. Mr. Andrew McIntyre, Out-going Chairman of the Civil College of the IEAust
2. Mr. Paul Mitchell, In-coming Chairman of the
Japan Society of Civil Engineers
1. Dr. Hiroshi Okada, Out-going Chair of the Executive Committee, ACECC
2. Mr. Michio Suzuki, President, JSCE
3. Mr. Itsuji Miyoshi, Executive Director, JSCE
4. Mr. Junichi Yoshikawa, Manager, International Affairs Section, JSCE
ACECC
1. Dr. Osamu Kusakabe, Secretary General, ACECC
2. Ms. Emiko Serino
2nd CECAR LOC
1. Dr. Yukihiko Sumiyoshi, Chair of the Local Organizing Committee
2. Dr. Masaaki Terashi, Secretary General of the LOC
3. Dr. Fuminao Okumura, LOC Secretary for General Affair
?€
AGENDA
===============================================================
1. Welcome by the JSCE President (Mr. Suzuki)
2. Greeting by the ACECC Chair of the Executive Committee (Dr. Okada)
3. Introduction of Attendees (Attachment-1)Confirmation of official representatives and quorum
4. New Membership Approval ( IEAust. Attachment-2))
5. Proposal and Approval of TC establishment (Attachment-3)
6. 2000 Activity report (Attachment-4))
7. 2000 Financial Report and Approval (Attachment-5)
8. Discussion and possible action on the amendment to By-laws pertaining
to ACECC Secretariat Office (Attachment-6)
9. Report of the 2nd CECAR from LOC (Attachment-7)
10. Election of New Chair of the Executive Committee (2001-2004)
remarks: Out-going Chair and the new Chair
(Chair will change from Dr. Okada to the new president elected)
11. Appointment and Approval of Secretary General
remarks: out-going Secretary General and the new Secretary General
12. Approval of the members of Local organizing committee (Attachment-8)
13. Report of initial plan for the 3rd CECAR (Attachment-9)
14. 2001 Action plan and budget plan (Attachment-10)
15. Any other business
16. Next Meeting
Agenda Item 1- Welcome by JSCE President
On behalf of the Japan Society of Civil Engineers, Mr. Michio Suzuki, JSCE President, welcomed all the attendees and expressed his gratitude for their support and cooperation extended to the LOC to make the 2nd CECAR successful.
Agenda Item 2 ??Greeting from ACECC Chair
Dr. Hiroshi Okada, out-going ACECC Chair, expressed his appreciation for the efforts and devotion made by the members to make the 2nd CECAR successful, which is one of the most important events of the ACECC. He specially referred to the ACECC flag with great gratitude, which was donated by KSCE with favorable approvals from all the members and displayed in the meeting room. He also made a special remark that this meeting would be the last one presided by him and the latter part of the agenda items would be presided by the new Chair.
Agenda Item 3 ??Introduction of Attendees (Attachment-1) and confirmation of official representatives and quorum
Every attendee made a brief self-introduction and the confirmation of the formal representative who had a voting right from each member society/institution was made as follows:
ASCE ??Dr. Alfred Ang
CICHE ??Dr. John Chien-Chung Li
JSCE ??Dr. Hiroshi Okada
KSCE ??Dr. Kwang-Il Kim
PICE ??Mr. Efren H. Sison
VCA ??Dr. Nugyen Truong Tien
The ACECC Secretary General ??Dr. Osamu Kusakabe
Since there was no absence from any of the members, the meeting was confirmed effective according to the Constitution Article 5-7.
Agenda Item 4 ??New Membership Approval (IEAust. Attachment-2)
Dr. Kusakabe made some brief explanation about this issue which had been left pending since the 3rd Executive Committee Meeting showing the e-mail correspondence between Mr. McIntyre of IEAust and the Secretariat. Mr. McIntyre explained that the Congress of IEAust was held in the previous week in
Agenda Item 5 ??Proposal and Approval of TC establishment (Attachment-3)
Dr. Kusakabe showed the participants the "Proposed Amendment of Procedures for establishing a Technical Committee", which was discussed and approved at the 2nd Executive Committee Meeting. To avoid unnecessary confusion, Dr. Kusakabe proposed to add one sentence to 5 of the Procedures for establishing a Technical Committee, as was shown in Attachment-3. There was a question about wording of "the host member" and Dr. Kusakabe explained that the definition of the "host society" should be the society who submits a proposal to create a Technical Committee (TC) and that society should be responsible for the management or operations of the TC, but not responsible for funding of the TC. The host society will organize a TC but is not responsible for providing its budget. There were several comments and suggestions about the wording in Attachment-3. Dr. Kusakabe proposed the final wording as "The host member society/institution for a technical committee is responsible for managing the Technical Committee. The Technical Committee members are responsible for their traveling and living expenses" and it was agreed unanimously.
For future clarification, it was agreed to record the suggestions from Mr. Sison that a phrase "no expense from ACECC" should be added to avoid any misinterpretation. Although it is up to the Executive Committee to decide whatever expenses be spent to support a TC, the phrase would make it very clear that any expense coming from a technical committee should be borne by the technical committee in principle.
Dr. Kusakabe reported that there were two proposals for TC establishment from JSCE (Attachment-3): "TC on Asian and Pacific Coastal Network", and "TC on Integrated river basin management". The key terms of reference for the TCs are, as is stated in the Constitution Article 8.1, to establish the network and then identify technical subjects in a particular area. The idea behind this statement is each society has its own research committees and if technical committees are organized then integrated issues can be presented in the nearest CECAR.
Dr. Chon, KSCE Vice President commented as follows: KSCE agree with the establishment of the technical committees proposed by JSCE as both of these committees deal with the regional issues requiring coordinated efforts of the ACECC members, however, one word of caution is that there are already existing studies, for instance, between the coastal engineering of Korea, China and Japan. Therefore the technical committees should find ways to link with these on-going study teams so that the committee activities should not be duplicated or in conflict with the existing studies. Mr. Raufaste, ASCE, made a comment that he would like all the participants to seriously consider the creation of additional technical committees based on appropriate information and conclusions from the CECAR2 Sessions. We should be able to build at least one or two more technical committees from the exciting technologies that we will be hearing during the next two days. Those proposals should be made at the 5th Executive Committee Meeting.
(A short recess)
Agenda Item 6 ??2000 Activity Report (Attachment-4)
Dr. Kusakabe reported the ACECC Activity for the year
(1) There were two executive committee meetings in 2000 and the key issues discussed were reported.
(2) The preparation for the 2nd CECAR was progressed by tremendous efforts of the LOC chaired by Dr. Sumiyoshi.
(3) Membership campaign ??VCA became a member and IEAust has expressed their intention to join ACECC. The invitation to ACECC and the information about the 2nd CECAR have been constantly sent to ICE, ECCE, IE.New Zealand, EI.Thailand, IE.Singapore, IE.Hong Kong,
(4) Secretariat Report ?? What the Secretariat did during the year of 2000 was shown.
(5) Homepage ??The updated homepage articles were shown.
A question was raised about the probability of the above mentioned societies/institutions entering ACECC. Dr. Kusakabe said he received an e-mail from the Institution of Thailand saying that they want to be a member of ACECC this year and also he received an impression that
Agenda Item 7 ??2000 Financial Report and Approval (Attachment-5)
The 2000 ACECC Account Report which had been audited with signature was circulated to the attendees. It was reported that the balance at the end of the year 2000 was negative US$2,843.84. The reason: the membership due payments from PICE and VCA were delayed. VCA paid the dues for the year of
As to the issue raised by Mr.Sison concerning the fiscal year at the time of 3rd Executive Committee Meeting, Dr. Kusakabe said that the Secretariat had looked into the documents very carefully from the first to the latest documents of the executive committee meetings, and summarized our previous understanding, as was shown in Attachment-5. From the Attachment, it was confirmed that we had agreed that each member pay $2,000 by December 1999 for the year of 1999 and from the 2000 fiscal year (1 January to 31 December) each member pay $2,000 before 30 June every year. The financial report was then unanimously approved.
Agenda Item 8 ??Discussion and possible action on the amendment to By-laws pertaining to ACECC Secretariat (Attachment-6)
Dr. Okada made some special comments about the item 8. This issue was originated by Dr. Kim, KSCE at the 3rd ECM in
Mr. Cruz, PICE, said that although PICE was going to mention that they were ready to have the permanent office in
Dr. Chon commented that by proposing to locate the next Secretariat in
Agenda Item 9 ??Report of the 2nd CECAR from LOC (Attachment-7)
Dr. Sumiyoshi reported that since the last Executive Committee in
Dr. Terashi showed the final conference program to be distributed to each participant. Some of the points he pointed out were, (1) There would be simultaneous translation service at the main room for the Japanese participants; the cost will be paid by JSCE. (2) The visit to
(Lunch was taken)
Agenda Item 10 ??Election of New Chair of the Executive Committee (2000-2004)
According to the By-laws I.2, the representative of the member society/institution who will host the next International Conference shall be the chair and it is already decided that the 3rd CECAR will be hosted by the Korean Society of Civil Engineers at the 3rd Executive Committee Meeting. Dr. Okada asked KSCE to recommend a person to be the new Chair of the ACECC and KSCE recommended President Kwang-Il Kim be the Chair, and it was approved unanimously.
(Dr. Okada?塜 Greeting - First I congratulate Dr. Kim on his being elected the next Chair of ACECC. Taking this opportunity I would like to express my sincere gratitude to each member of the executive committee. ACECC was founded in September 1999. The Constitution and By-laws were decided on, the number of the member societies/institutions has increased to six and the 2nd CECAR, one of the most important activities of the ACECC is going to successfully start from this evening. All of these achievements could not be materialized without your guidance, assistance and strenuous efforts and I would like to express my deep thank to Secretary General Dr. Kusakabe and the ACECC secretary. They executed their duties very earnestly, sincerely and efficiently. However, it is my regret that the number of the member societies/institutions did not increase remarkably and I feel responsible for it. Fortunately, the new Chair-elect, Dr. Kwang-Il Kim, is a distinguished civil engineer who has abundant experiences in international affairs. He is a man of amiable personality and vigorous leadership. I firmly believe that ACECC will continue to grow under the remarkable leadership of Dr. Kim. Every member?塜 incessant assistance for the new Chair is always highly appreciated. Lastly, personally I have very much enjoyed for these one and a half years acquiring close and warm friendship with all of you. I sincerely wish ACECC last forever and develop further.
Dr. Kwang-Il Kim?塜 Greeting ??Thank you for your approval. It is a great honor for me to serve as a new Chair of the ACECC Executive Committee for the next 3 years. I would like to especially thank Dr. Okada for his dedicated leadership and for having achieved so much in less than 2 years??time, I also would like to congratulate Dr. Sumiyoshi and his team of LOC for making this 2nd CECAR such a great success. Since my predecessor has done such a wonderful job, it will be hard for me to do any better. But I will exert my best efforts to firmly establish ACECC as the prominent intersocietal civil engineering organization in the Asian region. In order to achieve this goal, I need your strong support and active participation as ACECC broadens its activities I thank you for the support you have already given me, and I pledge my best as the new Chair. Thank you very much.)
The Chair was changed from Dr. Okada to Dr. Kwang-Il Kim.
Agenda Item 11 ?? Appointment and approval of Secretary General
Dr. Kwang-Il Kim, the new Chair, nominated Dr. Chun-Su Chon as the new Secretary General of ACECC, and the nomination was unanimously approved (By-laws, I.3). He also appointed the out-going Secretary General, Dr. Osamu Kusakabe, as the Executive Advisor to the new Chair and the new Secretary General. The appointment was also approved.
Agenda Item 12 ??Approval of the members of Local Organizing Committee (Attachment-8)
Dr. Kim recommended Dr. Sung-Wan Hong, one of the International Directors of KSCE, as the Chair of LOC for the 3rd CECAR, and the Executive Committee unanimously approved the recommendation. Dr. Hong will organize the remaining officers of LOC and report at the next Executive Committee Meeting for the approval.
Dr. Hong expressed his hope that IEAustralia would join ACECC in the nearest future to participate in the 3rd CECAR as an ACECC member. He asked ASCE if they were going to participate in the 3rd CECAR, for ASCE had said at the Seattle Meeting that they had not committed anything beyond the 2nd CECAR. Mr. Raufaste, ASCE, responded that the decision would be made at their board meeting in July. Although ACECC?塜 successful CECAR would certainly be steps to a right direction they had no decision until their July meeting. Dr. Ang, ASCE, asked if the $30,000 contribution for loan would be required for the CECAR-3, since he would have to make a proposal at the ASCE board meeting for approval to join CECAR-3 and they might want to know how much commitment would be required. In relation to the issue, Dr. Chon touched on a problem about how to distribute the surplus from the 2nd CECAR. Although the By-laws indicates that 40% of the surplus should go to ACECC and the rest of it be divided among the three funding members, if there was another loan that ACECC could be run by the donations and if those members would donate the surplus, then the amount of loan could be reduced.
Dr. Ang?塜 showed his understanding that 40% of the surplus should go to ACECC and the rest should be divided by the three funding members. Dr. Kusakabe explained that at the steering committee in Manila in June, 1999 there was a discussion that the 40% should go to the Council and 20% to each funding society, but this is not the matter stipulated in the ACECC By-laws and remains to be discussed. Dr. Ang said there are two major points to be discussed; (1), The surplus from CECAR-2 really should be equally divided among the three funding societies, and (2), In CECAR-3, how is the surplus going to be distributed and also how much money you need from each society. However, as far as the 2nd CECAR is concerned, the surplus should go to the three funding societies because they loaned $30,000 each, which was kind of an investment because they had a risk. Dr. Chon, the new Secretary General, suggested that the decision should be carried forward to the next Executive Committee Meeting. Dr. Li, CICHE, expressed his opinion that the surplus was accrued from contribution by all the members. Loan is loan, not investment. Surplus should be divided by all the members or everything should go to ACECC. Dr. Ang said it would be OK with CECAR-3, but as far as CECAR-2 is concerned, the previous agreement should be adapted. Dr. Kusakabe pointed out the fact that the surplus expected now turned out to be much bigger than our expectation because of the good contributions from
As to the initial members of Local Organizing Committee, Dr. Hong will ask the other members to recommend Honorary International Advisors later and he will submit more details at the next Executive Committee Meeting.
Agenda Item 13 ??Report of initial plan for the 3rd CECAR (Attachment ??)
Dr. Hong reported that they are planning the date for the 3rd CECAR to be during the 3rd week of August 2004, five days including technical tours. The venue will be Sheraton Walker Hill,
ASCE suggested an idea to hold the next ECM in
Agenda Item 14 ??
The main agenda items planned for the 5th ECM and the 6th ECM were reported. Also the budget for the 2001 was reported. Dr. Kim said that the detailed action plans including the financial matters will be reported at the next ECM.
Agenda Item 15 ??Any other business
(1) Dr. Li, CICHE, expressed their hope to organize the 4th CECAR. Dr. Chon thanked Dr. Li for his offer and requested that CICHI make an application in a written form so that we can discuss the matter at the future Executive Committee Meeting based on the nomination procedures approved at the 2nd ECM.
(2) Dr. Li mentioned that they have a master framework to establish a TC and they would like to make a proposal at the next ECM. Dr. Kusakabe said before the next ECM, the Secretariat will ask other members??opinions and they will have a draft for discussion.
(3) Dr. Okada expressed his opinion that as to the surplus of the 2nd CECAR, he would like to follow the conclusion of this ECM, that is, 40% to ACECC, 20% each to the three funding members, however, he hoped that this matter would be discussed at the next ECM and decided that 100% of the surplus should belong to ACECC. Dr. Ang expressed his opinion that in order to share the surplus equally, each member society should also provide a loan equally to ACECC, then, there would certainly be no problem in dividing the surplus. This issue should be taken again at the next ECM.
Agenda Item 16 ??Next Meeting
Dr. Kim offered the next ECM to be







